Reimagining Us podcast show image

Reimagining Us

Nichole Argo

Podcast

Episodes

Listen, download, subscribe

Power as Care: Designing Civic Life People Want to Join

People want to contribute to their communities. So why do so many feel disconnected from the places where decisions get made? This episode opens in a room Scott has sat in more times than he can count: smart, caring leaders who understand the data, nod at every point, and conclude they can’t act. But the world outside that room has changed. A rising tide of disconnection and division has altered the environment every community lives in, and that changes what’s being asked of the institutions that organize everyday life: schools and libraries, churches and nonprofits, foundations, municipal staff, and local leaders. In this episode of Reimagining Us, Nichole and Scott ask whether this moment hands those institutions a new responsibility, and opportunity: nurturing connection and collaboration within the community, e.g., the health of civic life itself. Institutions inherit routines, norms, and ways of engaging the public that can persist long after they stop working well — and organizationally, changing course can feel risky. Nichole and Scott make an honest case for operating as usual — for institutional neutrality — but also examine the consequences of letting inaction become the default. They even find, inside the most famous defense of institutional neutrality ever written — the University of Chicago’s 1967 Kalven Report — the exception that changes everything: when something threatens an institution’s very mission, neutrality is no longer an option. And for community institutions, that exception is the point. Their mission is community — its connection, its trust, its capacity to solve problems together. When those fray, engaging isn’t a departure from the mission. It is the mission. The question, in other words, is mission-critical. Featuring Kristen Scott Kennedy, Executive Vice President of the Council on Foundations, and Daniel Stid, board chair of More in Common and author of The Art of Association, the episode moves from bridging and belonging to a deeper question of agency: Do people have meaningful opportunities to speak, contribute, deliberate, and shape the communities they live in? Drawing on their own and others’ local-level research, the hosts argue that the answer is less about convincing people to care and more about redesigning the containers we ask them to enter. Stid tells the story of a beautiful park near his home, fenced off for eighteen months, and the contentious public meeting that showed him why participation has to feel like something worth returning to. A public meeting, a community dinner, a library, or a grantmaking process can either make civic life feel aversive….or create an experience people want to come back to. The episode ultimately offers a different way to think about institutional power: power as care. Not simply delivering services, but stewarding the norms, spaces, and processes that help communities build relationships, exercise voice, and solve problems together. The takeaway? If people are willing to participate but lack meaningful opportunities to do so, disconnection is not simply a personal problem. It is a design problem, and we need our institutions to help solve it. Key Discussion Points Why Institutions Hold Back: Familiar routines, perceived risk, and institutional inertia can make inaction feel safer than change. When Neutrality Serves a Purpose: Neutrality can protect trust, pluralism, and institutional mission, but it should be chosen deliberately, not by default. Connection Needs Agency: Bridging relationships matter, but belonging is incomplete if people still lack meaningful voice in decisions that affect them. Participation Is Designed: The norms and processes surrounding civic engagement help determine whether people return, or walk away. The Opportunity Gap: Many Americans say they want to connect and contribute but lack clear opportunities to do so. Power as Care: Institutions can use their freedom and resources to create durable civic infrastructure that strengthens community over time. Practical Takeaways Look at the container, not just the participant. If people are disengaging, examine whether the experience of participation is welcoming, meaningful, and consequential. Create real pathways to agency. Give people opportunities not only to attend or speak, but to influence what happens next. Treat neutrality as a choice. Ask what your institution exists to protect, and what action or inaction means for that mission. Design for return. Build civic experiences people want to come back to, not ones that require extraordinary willpower to endure. Invest for the long term. Connection, trust, and civic capacity grow through sustained institutions, relationships, and spaces, not one-off programs. Use power as care. Ask how your institution’s authority, resources, and convening power can help a community participate, connect, and shape its future.

Reimagining Us RSS Feed


Share: Twitter • Facebook

Powered by Plink Plink icon plinkhq.com